By Gerald Posner
The word “genocide” has been attached to only one side of this war: Israel. The event that started it, the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel three years ago this Wednesday, appears in discussions of genocide mostly as backstory.
This past August I wrote a rigorous primer that examined the word genocide under international law, what is required to satisfy its explicit standards, and why Gaza did not meet that test. That piece carried the irreverent title, Genocide for Dummies, but that undersells a serious legal analysis that went viral.
Writing it got me thinking about a narrower and very different question: If the 1948 Genocide Convention’s list of prohibited acts and “special intent” requirement were applied to October 7, did Hamas commit a genocidal act on that day?
The international organizations that have weighed in with opinions on genocide—the UN Commission of Inquiry, the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS), Amnesty International, and the Israe…




