38 Comments
User's avatar
Monuments of Suffering's avatar

Always clear, rigorously researched, unbiased. Thank you.

Andrew Hastie MP's avatar

I read your book ‘Case Closed’ as a 12 year old kid. A brilliant book. Grateful for your ongoing fact-based reasoning and investigation at this time.

Gerald Posner's avatar

Smart 12-year-old! )

David Atkinson's avatar

well, Case Closed is kind-of like a sequel to The Hardy Boys.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Dec 24, 2024
Comment deleted
Gerald Posner's avatar

The assassination of president John Kennedy -

Chris Foreman's avatar

Turning people into human threat-assessment machines who then interact with one another under conditions of uncertainty and rapid-response is not ever going to be flawless. Thanks for taking the time to examine carefully and avoid getting out ahead of the evidence.

QX's avatar

Even if they couldn't have gotten to Crooks in time, at the least they could've communicated to the SS and police near Trump and the stage to immediately take Trump away to remove the target. Why was there a communications break down of this monumental proportion?

Gerald Posner's avatar

Exactly. What is supposed to happen is that everyone hears in their earpieces GUN! GUN! GUN! and the agents rush and cover the candidate and get him out of there as fast as possible

Abigail Starke's avatar

Thank you for this report. agonizing, frustrating, and infuriating to read though. The crowd was more alert than the secret service and police.

Julie's avatar

And witnesses in the crowd would have been experiencing an unsettling type of cognitive dissonance while expecting something that failed to happen: an appropriate enforcement and security response to what they correctly saw as a significant threat.

J Vee's avatar

This is the most clear and concise timeline breakdown I’ve seen. Thank you for your excellent reporting - on every topic you cover.

Lisa and Elliot Jager's avatar

Thanks for this most helpful post. An old fan. Elliot Jager

Jaynee Beach's avatar

What do you know of the reports that a SS officer had sights on Crooks before any shooting happened, and was repeatedly told to hold his fire? Can that be verified?

Also, I have read that after Crooks fired, this same SS officer then shot Crooks; and was later fired for doing so? Can that be verified? (Or ruled out)

Gerald Posner's avatar

Don't know yet. Those are good questions that must still be answered.

Dory Wiley's avatar

All very good. Keep up the good work. Your are coming around!

DB's avatar

"It's not the crime, it's the cover up."

How many times have we seen the government and corporations steal defeat from the jaws of victory by not being transparent or outright lying because they fear embarrassment or liability and turn it into something much worse.

This, along with the coverup of the Biden memory issues, reminds me of the death spiral that the Jimmy Carter administration faced after the Iran embassy takeover and failed Iran hostage rescue debacle. Even though they did admit most of their failures reasonably quickly, nobody trusted anything the government told them and that helped doom his reelection.

I suspect enough of this information will also come out from witnesses to quickly torpedo attempts to spin things and deflect blame for a series of obvious failures.

Then there will be the inevitable Congressional politicized witch-hunts that may have subpoena power to assist them.

Maybe someone in power should just raise their hand and tell it like we all know it is before this turns into another endless (and likely unwarranted) conspiracy story.

Don's avatar

This is not the JFK assassination case. Only Lone Nut Buffs continue to believe in the Warren Commission garbage. Wake up and stop ignoring the facts revealed since the 90s.

Christopher Petersen's avatar

Thank you Gerald. Knowing your meticulous & exacting research with Trisha, you probably have had a timeline on the wall & are filling in the blanks as information comes in. We all look forward to what you explain to us as this develops. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Chris Gay's avatar

Re: budget constraints -- one more example of something that should be done thoroughly, not "efficiently," no matter what it costs. Efficiency is often the enemy of thoroughness.

Todd Maisel's avatar

I think you miss an important point. When local cops hear that a man is on the roof, why aren't they communicating this to Secret Service? What I suspect is that there was no central command post where reps of all law enforcement are stationed and that there was no interoperability between law enforcement. Radios couldn't talk to one another. Nobody could warn each other. Local cops were kept outside perimeter and couldn't confir with Secret Service. This is a mandated federal obligation and Secret Service and the local jurisdiction failed. Damn shame.

Steve L's avatar

"There is a story behind the Trump assassination. I just don't know what it is yet.” Ditto JFK, Gerald.

XxYwise's avatar

Everything went exactly that way Trump intended.

XxYwise's avatar

Did you notice he wasn't actively bleeding? And then Hulk Hogan shows up at the convention just to rub our noses in it...

Robb Cochran's avatar

A Gerald Posner article on the Trump assassination? Jeez, you just made my weekend.